Hardy Chicago vs. Brown Turkey vs. Celeste: Which Fig Tree Should You Grow?
Hardy Chicago, Celeste and Brown Turkey are three of the most common fig varieties you'll find in the United States, whether you're at a local nursery or shopping around online. This guide covers all three so you can make the right choice before you plant one.
They're not equal. Each one has a different set of genes, and those genes drive traits like cold hardiness, rain resistance, flavor and ripening time that can make or break a fig tree in your climate. In fact, for about 80% of you reading this in the United States, Brown Turkey is one of the worst fig varieties you could grow.
And these three are only a small slice of what's out there. There are thousands of fig varieties, and I keep track of them in my Fig Variety Directory. At Fig Boss, we also sell the fig trees. I've been growing figs in the Philadelphia area since 2014, and over the last decade I've trialed somewhere around 400 to 500 varieties myself, including all three of these.
If you've already done some research, you may have noticed that a lot of the growing descriptions, and even the photos, on nursery listings online are regurgitated and copy-pasted from some random source. A lot of it is also wrong. If you want the truth about these three figs from someone who has grown them, this article is for you.
Table of Contents
What You Need to Know First
The Fig Trees in This Comparison
Side-by-Side Comparison Table
First, Which Brown Turkey?
Meet the Three Figs
Cold Hardiness
Taste
Fig Size
Ripening Time
Rain and Split Resistance
Breba Crop
Pots or In-Ground
Which One Should You Grow? My Pick by Climate and Zone
The General Consensus vs. My Take
What I'd Grow Instead or Alongside: Violette de Bordeaux
FAQ
Final Thoughts
What You Need to Know First
Before we get into all that, here's a quick rundown of the three figs. If you'd rather skip ahead, be my guest. The table of contents above will take you anywhere in the article.
Hardy Chicago: The standard for cold hardiness, and the best-tasting of the three when it's perfectly ripe. Small to medium figs with a jammy berry flavor, early ripening and good rain resistance. It has over 100 names, and the source you get matters a lot.
Celeste: My overall pick of the three. Small, sweet, very early figs with a skin that sheds rain better than almost anything. It reaches its best flavor more consistently than the other two, and it's almost as hardy as Hardy Chicago.
Brown Turkey: Last of the three. Two different figs share the name, California Brown Turkey and English Brown Turkey. Both are inferior to many other fig varieties, and I'll explain why below.
If you're just getting started with figs, read my guide to growing fig trees too. It covers the basics that matter no matter which variety you pick.
Get a Hardy Chicago fig tree: Hardy Chicago (Figoro) | Hardy Chicago (Azores Dark) | Get a Celeste fig tree: Celeste | Celeste (The One) | Black Celeste | Instead of Brown Turkey: Green Michurinska | Golden Rainbow | Dalmatie (Stella) | Alongside them: Violette de Bordeaux
The Fig Trees in This Comparison
Want to compare more? Browse all of my fig trees for sale, my cold-hardy fig trees, my early fig trees or the Fig Variety Directory.
Side-by-Side Comparison Table
If you want to compare these against hundreds of other figs, use my master variety table. You can filter by cold hardiness, brebas, rain resistance, early ripening and more.
First, Which Brown Turkey?
“Brown Turkey” is two completely different figs that share a name. Before you compare it to anything, you need to know which one you have.
California Brown Turkey
This is what most people in the U.S. know simply as “Brown Turkey.” It's the one sold at big-box stores and the one you'll see all over the South. In the U.S., you may also hear it called Texas Blue Giant or Black Jack. A slightly larger strain is common in Japan as Masui Dauphine, and it's a staple for commercial growers around the world. It's a large fig with firm, durable skin, which is why it ships so well.
I found one fig hunting in Cape May, New Jersey. I thought it might be something unique. It turned out to be California Brown Turkey.
English Brown Turkey (Olympian)
This is a different fig. It's the Brown Turkey that's widely grown in England, and it became very popular in Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Germany, Belgium and the Netherlands for its cold tolerance and its reliable breba crop. In the U.S., it's known as Olympian, after Olympia, Washington, where it was found. When the USDA tested Olympian, it came up as unique in their collection, but seasoned collectors recognize it as English Brown Turkey.
What Isn't Brown Turkey
Vern's Brown Turkey, a popular fig in the Pacific Northwest, is nothing like Brown Turkey. It's named after garden writer Vern Nelson. And in the South, Brown Turkey often gets confused with Celeste. Put the two side by side and you'll never confuse them again.
There's also a third fig people call Southern Brown Turkey. That's actually Hardy Chicago. So even though it's called Southern Brown Turkey, it's Hardy Chicago. Celeste and Brown Turkey get confused all the time, and Southern Brown Turkey gets confused with the two of them all the time as well.
Celeste and Brown Turkey are probably the most common fig varieties in the United States, especially on the East Coast. They're really popular in the South. Celeste is really common along the shore and the coastal areas, and Brown Turkey is really popular in southern climates. Hardy Chicago is more popular in the Northeast, especially around major cities.
For the full story, read my reviews of California Brown Turkey and Olympian (English Brown Turkey). If you're wondering how one fig ends up with so many names, see fig variety synonyms and fig variety genetic testing.
Meet the Three Figs
Hardy Chicago
Hardy Chicago is the most well-known hardy fig in the world, and the standard every other fig gets measured against for cold hardiness. I can walk around different parts of Philly and find it everywhere. It has over 100 names, from Malta Black and Azores Dark to Bensonhurst Purple, because it came to North America with Italian, French, Portuguese and Middle Eastern families. That also means the source matters a lot. I've tasted Hardy Chicago from big old trees in Philly and Jersey, picked at perfect ripeness, and they didn't come close to the best sources you can grow.
Celeste
Celeste is the fig I measure every other fig against for humid climates. It's not the most flavorful fig, but almost nothing handles rain better. It has 30 or more names, but after trialing more than 10 sources, I found most of them are almost indistinguishable, unlike Hardy Chicago. It's also the parent behind much of LSU's breeding program. My favorite version is Black Celeste, a bud sport with the same growing traits and a much stronger berry flavor.
Brown Turkey
California Brown Turkey is a commercial fig for commercial growers. It's not really meant for home growers, even though you'll find it at nurseries everywhere, and even for commercial growing, there are at least 15 varieties I would choose before it. English Brown Turkey's two main benefits are its breba crop and its cold hardiness. But figs I cover in this article, like Violette de Bordeaux, Green Michurinska and Vagabond, are hardy and produce brebas too, and they're better figs overall.
I'll be straight with you: both Brown Turkeys are inferior to many, many other fig varieties. They're popular because they're what most people know. A lot of people like to can Brown Turkey, but you can can any fig. You can grow a fig that's just as large, cans just as well and does better on rain resistance, hardiness and plenty of other traits. There's no significant trait that puts Brown Turkey above other figs.
I know a lot of people love their Brown Turkey and their Olympian, and I understand that. These are just the findings from trialing hundreds of fig varieties over the last decade. Take my word for it, try something new and see what happens.
Cold Hardiness
Hardy Chicago is the hardiest of the three and the standard for cold climates, and Celeste is almost as hardy, if not just as hardy. English Brown Turkey is also very hardy. California Brown Turkey is hardier than average.
Hardy Chicago: It can handle about 0°F without real winter protection, as long as you get it through the first winter without much damage and learn how to prune it. Back in 2017 to 2019, my Hardy Chicago and Little Ruby trees took no damage at 2°F. In the 2024–25 winter, with three nights at 4–6°F, it was again one of my best performers.
Celeste: Celeste is very hardy, almost as hardy as Hardy Chicago, if not just as hardy. It consistently survives 0°F or close to it, in my yard and for growers in other locations. It was on my list of best performers in the 2024–25 winter, too, although the Celeste in my worst plot took some damage.
English Brown Turkey: One of the most cold-hardy figs there is, which is why it spread across northern Europe.
California Brown Turkey: Hardier than average.
Keep in mind, no variety is winter-proof. In the 2025–26 winter, it got down to -3 to 2°F here, and almost every unprotected tree died back to the ground, Hardy Chicago and Celeste included. A tree that isn't lignified, or hardened off, going into winter can even take damage at 20–25°F. I explain this in the secret to cold-hardy fig trees, and I list more hardy varieties in cold-tolerant fig trees. For protection methods in zones 5, 6 and 7, read my masterclass on hardy fig trees in cold climates.
Shop: cold-hardy fig trees
Taste
Perfectly ripe, the difference between these three is very minor, and at that point you're splitting hairs. Hardy Chicago tastes the best of the three when it's perfectly ripe. But my winner is Celeste, because it reaches that perfect eating experience the most consistently and the most often, in humid or dry climates. That reliability is what makes the best-tasting fig.
Hardy Chicago: Jammy, with a berry flavor. Most sources taste like blueberry or mild strawberry, combined with a dried fig flavor and high sweetness. Malta Black can taste like raspberries. My favorite source for years has been Azores Dark, for its earthiness, high sweetness and Concord grape and blueberry flavor. When Hardy Chicago dries or shrivels on the tree, the flavor intensifies a lot. Only then would I put it with the best-tasting figs. Picked too soon, you can find better-tasting figs.
Celeste: Your classic sugar fig. It's sweet, with melon tones and some dried fruit flavor. It tastes like a fig in its most basic sense. Let it fully ripen on the tree and it picks up a hint of Concord grape, so I put it in the Sugar Berry group. When it dries on the tree, it's like a little sugar bomb.
In a dry climate, Celeste dries on the tree nearly every time, and that's when it tastes best. No sun drying, dehydrator or oven needed. Hardy Chicago can also dry on the tree, but it takes a lot longer, and it isn't as good or as consistent at it.
California Brown Turkey: A sugar berry fig with a jelly-like texture. It sits in the Average tier of my best-tasting fig varieties list. Properly ripened in a dry climate, it actually tastes pretty good. In my humid climate, it rarely gets there. In the South, a lot of people pick it early and can it in sugar syrup to make up for the lack of flavor.
English Brown Turkey: A jammy sugar berry fig. It's also in the Average tier. Even in ideal hot, dry climates, the flavor is unremarkable.
To be fair, both Brown Turkeys taste good when they're properly ripened, and that happens more often in a dry climate. Everywhere else, expect problems. In my own yard, and in many reports from other growers, they get a lot of bugs, often don't fully ripen, and spoil and mold easily. And even perfectly ripened in the most ideal climate, neither one is top of the line for texture or flavor.
In humid climates, fruit quality is less consistent in general, and both Brown Turkeys are much worse than the other two. Compare Celeste to either Brown Turkey on consistency and fruit quality, and it's night and day.
For more on flavor groups, read what do figs taste like or browse my Fig Flavor Directory.
Fig Size
California Brown Turkey is the biggest of the group, and that's its main selling point. English Brown Turkey is medium, Hardy Chicago is small to medium, and Celeste is small.
If size is what you're after, Brown Turkey isn't the best choice. Dalmatie and Longue d'Aout are both larger, produce 200–300 gram brebas, are hardier and more productive, and taste considerably better. If you want a large, vigorous, productive fig that delivers on flavor in humid and dry areas, I'd point you toward Golden Rainbow.
Ripening Time
Celeste: One of the earliest figs in my yard every year. It ripens a lot of figs at once to start the season, so plan to pick often.
Hardy Chicago: The mark for what counts as an early fig. Growers will say things like “Ronde de Bordeaux ripens two weeks earlier than Hardy Chicago.” In my yard, it ripens around mid-August.
California Brown Turkey: Early.
English Brown Turkey: The main crop ripens mid-season to late. In a short season, you may struggle to ripen it and end up relying on the brebas.
More in my guides to early fig varieties and how to ripen figs earlier.
Rain and Split Resistance
Celeste wins this one easily. Hardy Chicago is good. Both Brown Turkeys struggle in the rain.
Celeste: Four traits work together: a waterproof skin, a teardrop shape, high sugar and a very short hang time. Water hits the skin and slides right off. Most figs are soft and vulnerable for about 6 to 7 days, but Celeste's window is 1 to 2 days, so you can pick before the rain.
Hardy Chicago: The figs rarely split, thanks to their pear shape, but the skin absorbs a bit more water than I'd like. That causes cracking and lowers fruit quality. I'd still put it in a higher echelon of figs for humid climates, and it holds up well in the rain.
California Brown Turkey: Poor. Its open eye invites ants and fruit flies, and with high humidity and summer rains, it splits, spoils and molds. In Philadelphia, a single day of rain can ruin the crop. In a humid climate, you'll be lucky to harvest 50% of the figs.
English Brown Turkey: Low rain and split resistance. The figs often split because of their large eye, and in humid weather they rarely ripen to high quality.
Read more in the best fig varieties for humid climates, figs with a short hang time, why figs split and why fig shape matters.
Breba Crop
English Brown Turkey: This is its standout trait. It produces a heavy, reliable breba crop, which extends the fig season by 30 to 45 days. On a trip to London in 2024, I saw what I believe is a very old English Brown Turkey on the grounds of Buckingham Palace, loaded with brebas starting around May 15th.
Hardy Chicago: I consider Hardy Chicago a one-crop fig, with no true breba. The light “breba” crops some people report are most likely main-crop figs that set late, made it through the winter and finished the next year. True brebas need dormancy after the wood forms.
Celeste: Not a breba producer, although I've seen the odd breba ripen on it.
California Brown Turkey: One crop only.
If you want brebas and great flavor in a hardy, rain-resistant tree, I'd grow Violette de Bordeaux, Green Michurinska or Vagabond. Read my guide to breba figs for more.
Shop: breba fig trees
Pots or In-Ground
Hardy Chicago: It does fine in a pot. I've had one in a 3-gallon pot put out close to 20 figs in a season.
Celeste: It's very sensitive to dry soil and drops its figs when the soil dries out, so in a pot, keep the watering consistent. Black Celeste does really well in pots and in the ground.
California Brown Turkey: About the same in a pot or in the ground.
English Brown Turkey: Better suited to the ground, where it can carry a big breba crop.
Which One Should You Grow? My Pick by Climate and Zone
Cold, short-season climates (Northeast, Midwest, zones 6–7): Hardy Chicago, from a good source. It can be grown in zone 6B with protection, and in zones 4 and 5 in containers. Celeste also handles the cold well. Protect young trees for the first few winters. See my Boston, NYC, Philadelphia, Baltimore & DC guide.
The humid South (zones 8–9): Celeste, or better yet Black Celeste. In zones 8B–11, you can plant Celeste any time of year. Skip California Brown Turkey unless you only want figs for canning. See my Richmond, Charlotte, Atlanta, Nashville & Houston guide.
Hot, dry climates (California, Arizona, West Texas): Hardy Chicago performs very well there, and California Brown Turkey can taste pretty decent in a dry place. But you can grow some of the most flavorful figs in the world, so I'd look beyond all three. For big figs, grow Dalmatie or Longue d'Aout.
Mild, cool summers (Pacific Northwest, northern Europe): This is where English Brown Turkey's brebas earn their keep. Still, Green Michurinska is just as hardy, produces brebas, ripens its main crop earlier and is way tastier, even in humid areas.
Commercial growing: California Brown Turkey's size and firm skin are why commercial growers like it, especially in hot, dry climates or under a greenhouse. For home growers, that doesn't matter.
A lot of people in the South used both Celeste and Brown Turkey for canning. They'd pick them underripe and preserve them in sugar. Truthfully, I think a better way to can figs is to can them unripe. I think they're better that way, personally. People are going to do what they want, but the main benefit of an unripe fig is that it stays firm. You can can figs picked underripe and they'll be firm, but unripe figs will be even more firm, and they have a totally different flavor and eating experience. I think it's better.
The General Consensus vs. My Take
All three of these figs have been tested over and over. My take comes from my own trials, but also from talking with thousands of growers over the years and reading thousands of forum posts. So most of what's in this article is the general consensus. Here's where I agree with it and where I don't.
Hardy Chicago: The general consensus is that it's the go-to fig for cold climates. I agree. I'd only add that the source matters a lot, and that perfectly ripe, it's the best-tasting of the three.
Celeste: The general consensus is that it's the go-to fig for humid climates. I agree, and I'd go further: it's my overall pick of the three. It reaches its best flavor more consistently than the other two, it dries on the tree in a dry climate, and it's almost as hardy as Hardy Chicago.
Brown Turkey: A lot of growers love it, mostly for canning and because it's the fig they know. This is where I differ. I find both Brown Turkeys inferior to many other figs. Any fig can be canned, and there are figs just as large that do better in rain and cold.





