top of page

The Worst Fig Varieties I've Grown: Overrated Figs & What to Grow Instead

4 minutes ago
12 min read
This article is about the worst fig varieties I've grown. I'm going to be transparent and honest with you, so you can avoid the mistakes I made, and the same mistakes thousands of other growers make when they buy their first fig tree.

I'm Ross, the “Fig Boss.” I've been growing fig trees since 2014, and over the last decade I've trialed somewhere around 400 to 500 different varieties. I've also talked with thousands of growers and read thousands of forum posts. So this isn't only my opinion. Where my take is different from what most growers say, I'll tell you.

Why does that matter? If you've been shopping around for fig trees online, you may have noticed that a lot of the variety descriptions, and even the photos, on nursery listings are copied and pasted from some other source. A lot of that information is also wrong. I'd rather tell you what I've actually seen.

You can look up the varieties I talk about here in my Fig Variety Directory, and I sell fig trees too. Along the way, I've gotten rid of a lot of varieties. My 2020 cull list alone had more than 40 names on it.

In this article, I'll go through the kinds of bad fig varieties I've run into, the drought problem that makes good figs look bad, and the four popular figs I think are the most overrated: Black Mission, English Brown Turkey (Olympian), California Brown Turkey and Columbaro Nero. For each one, I'll tell you what I'd grow instead.


One more thing before we start. Just because I think these varieties are inferior doesn't mean growing one is a bad thing. I'd rather have a fig tree than no fig tree at all. But if you have one of these, there's something better out there that you can grow, and a lot of the better ones aren't hard to find.


Table of Contents

What You Need to Know First


Before we get into the list, here's the quick rundown. If you already know this, feel free to skip ahead to the most overrated fig varieties.

The overrated figs on this list aren't dead or diseased trees. They grow fine, and they ripen without pollination. They're just average, and other varieties do the same job better.

I don't give varieties a number score anymore. When I talk about flavor, I use the tiers from my Best Tasting Fig Varieties list: My Personal Favorite, Best Tasting, Exceptional, Above Average, Average and Don't Recommend to Anyone.

A fig can also taste bad when the variety isn't the problem. Missing pollination and dry soil are the two big ones, and I cover both below.

Climate matters a lot. A fig that spoils and molds in a humid area can taste good in a hot, dry one. Brown Turkey is the best example of that.

The Fig Trees I Recommend Instead



Want to compare more? Browse all of my fig trees for sale or my Fig Variety Directory.

The 4 Kinds of Bad Fig Varieties


After years of trials, almost every fig I've gotten rid of fits into one of four groups: splitters, synonyms, figs with a better direct replacement, and Common figs that need pollination to taste good.

1. Varieties That Split Nonstop


Some varieties just split, over and over. A lot of the time, it comes down to the shape of the fig. Shape is hardwired genetically into the variety, but you can actually help change it. Planting the tree in the ground and pruning it in certain ways can both improve the shape of the fruit, and a better shape means less splitting. I cover this in why figs split and why the shape of a fig is so important.

Even so, some varieties aren't worth the trouble. Adam is a good example. It's an Egyptian variety, and it tastes great, but it split so badly for me that I got rid of it.



2. Synonyms: The Same Fig Under a Different Name


A lot of the varieties I got rid of were just copies of another variety. I'd grow a fig for a couple of years and realize it was the same fig I already had, under a different name. Sometimes I didn't know that would be the case. Other times I did it on purpose.

Say I'm looking for an improved Black Mission type, or an improvement to Celeste. I'll grow a bunch of varieties that should be relatively the same, or even identical, in the hope that one of them is actually different enough, or better than the original, through mutation or whatnot. Every now and then you find one. Black Celeste is a good example: it's a strain of Celeste with a very different fruit. But most of the time, you just end up growing the same fig by a different name. That's part of trialing.




3. Varieties With a Direct Replacement


Then there are figs that are inferior in some way because there's a direct replacement for them. The trait that makes the variety shine, whether that's hardiness, brebas or size, shows up in other varieties too, and those varieties have a bunch of other traits that make them better. Most of the overrated figs later in this article fall into this group.

4. Common Figs That Taste Like Cardboard Without Pollination


This group has some of the worst offenders. These are Common figs, which means they ripen without pollination. But some of them taste like cardboard unless they're pollinated. There's just not a whole lot of flavor. If you're not sure what a Common fig is, I explain the different types of fig trees here.

One I grew this year was Del Vespro, from a grower named Nikky. It turned out to be Common, and it just didn't impress me at all. Fane and Tolosa are the same way. Even though they're Common figs, they should be pollinated. Unpollinated Tolosa is in the Don't Recommend to Anyone tier on my Best Tasting Fig Varieties list.

Iraqi, a palmata hybrid, is one of the worst figs I've ever grown, and it's in the Don't Recommend to Anyone tier on my Best Tasting list. I think it probably needs pollination to improve.




Splitters and synonyms aren't the focus of this article, because most people never grow them. The figs I really want to talk about are the popular ones that ripen properly without pollination and are simply inferior. But first, a quick word on drought.

Drought Damage Isn't the Variety's Fault


Some people mistake the poor quality they see for a bad variety, when it's really drought or periods of dry soil.

Drought affects fig varieties in a couple of different ways. Depending on the variety, the first thing a fig tree will do in a drought is drop its leaves. Other varieties, like Celeste and Pastiliere, will drop their fruit.

Then there are varieties like Hardy Chicago and LSU Purple that hold onto their fruit. They'll lose their leaves, but the figs stay on the tree, and the figs take damage. When you rescue the tree, it perks back up, and it looks like the fruit is fine. Then, weeks later, when the figs are actually starting to ripen, you can see they're not ripening properly.

You might see that part of the outside of the fig doesn't look right. You cut it open, and some of the flower parts on the inside didn't develop properly. It doesn't taste very good. This phenomenon plagues a handful of varieties, so before you write a fig off, make sure it wasn't left dry.




The Most Overrated Fig Varieties


These figs ripen properly without pollination. They're not the bottom of the barrel. They're average or below average, and there are better figs that fill the same role.

These are some of the most popular fig varieties around, which is exactly why I want to talk about them. Here are the four I'd highlight.

Black Mission


Unpollinated, Black Mission doesn't taste good, and it's a poor performer anywhere that isn't hot and dry. The figs take too long to ripen, and you don't get consistent fruit. If I lived somewhere hot and dry, that wouldn't be as much of a problem. On my Best Tasting list, it's in the Average tier.

Here's the thing, though: pollinated, Black Mission is a respectable, great-tasting fig. If it were always pollinated, it wouldn't be on this list. The general consensus is that Black Mission is a classic, and in hot, dry places like California, it earns that. Outside of those climates, my experience has been very different. I go deeper on its history and limits in my Black Mission fig review.

There are also improvements to Black Mission. Sultane, Pernette Noire, Black Mission NL (a strain from Jon Verdick) and Risoulet all improve on it in different ways.



English Brown Turkey (Olympian)


English Brown Turkey, known in the US as Olympian, has two main benefits: it produces a lot of high-quality brebas, and it's cold hardy. But the varieties below do both of those things too, and they taste better and do better in humid climates. When it's fully ripe in a dry climate, English Brown Turkey tastes good. In humid climates, the figs often don't get fully ripe, they get bugs, and they spoil and mold easily. Even at its best, the texture and flavor aren't top-tier. It's in the Average tier on my Best Tasting list.

Some great breba producers are Green Michurinska, Vagabond, Moro de Caneva and Violette de Bordeaux. All four are in the Best Tasting tier, and they blow English Brown Turkey and Black Mission out of the water.







California Brown Turkey


California Brown Turkey is what most people in the US mean when they say “Brown Turkey.” It's a large fig, and it's a commercial fig. Really, it's a fig for commercial growers only, and even for a commercial orchard, there are at least 15 varieties I'd choose before it. Golden Rainbow is one: huge, early, rain-resistant figs with tough skin and firm fruit.

The number of people who complain to me about bugs in their Brown Turkey figs, and figs that spoil, is huge. You have to pick them at exactly the right time, or you lose them. Like English Brown Turkey, it tastes good when it's fully ripe in a dry climate, but most growers don't get that very often. It's in the Average tier on my Best Tasting list.

A lot of people grow Brown Turkey for canning. But you can can any fig, and there are varieties just as large that are great for canning and also handle rain and cold better.

My take vs. the general consensus: a lot of growers love Brown Turkey, and I understand why. It's the fig most people know, and that's a big reason it's so popular. But after trialing hundreds of varieties, I can't find one significant trait that puts either Brown Turkey above the better figs in this article. My advice is to take my word for it, try something new and see what happens.




Columbaro Nero


Columbaro Nero is a really popular Italian variety in the Northeast. It's very hardy, and it produces a light breba crop. The figs are a decent size, and it's in the Above Average tier on my Best Tasting list, but the eating experience I get from it isn't great. The figs split a lot, and in rainy or humid places, it's just not a great choice.

Again, there are varieties that directly replace it. If you want a hardy, rain-resistant fig with brebas, the breba producers I listed above are where I'd start, and my master variety table will show you more.


A Few More I Don't Recommend


A few other names I'd mention here: Mega Celeste, Motoso Preto and Bakio. Mega Celeste and Motoso Preto are both in the Don't Recommend to Anyone tier on my Best Tasting list, and Bakio is in the Average tier. Emalyn's Purple is another one. It's a Common fig, and so far it really hasn't been great for me. None of these have a whole lot going for them compared to what else is out there.


Why I Hate Selling Inferior Figs (and Why I Might Sell Brown Turkey Anyway)


Selling an inferior variety just continues its legacy.

I don't like selling inferior fig varieties. Every tree of an average variety that goes out the door keeps that variety going for another generation of growers. People should honestly stop selling some of these, but you're never going to stop people from selling a variety like Brown Turkey. It's one of the most searched-for fig varieties today, which is insane.

So I might start selling Brown Turkey myself. There's a market for it, and if that's what people want, I may offer it. Either way, the information is all here on my website. I'm not here to lie to anybody or hype anything up.



Someone Should Release an “Improved Brown Turkey”


Take the best replacement for California Brown Turkey, one that's better in many, many ways, and call it Improved Brown Turkey. You want Brown Turkey? Here's a better option.

Somebody will get a lot of flak for doing this, so I don't necessarily recommend it. But I think someone ought to do it. People wouldn't like it, but you'd really be doing them a favor.

If I were picking, I'd make that fig Torbole, which I also sell as Verte e Arte and Fico Lungo di Portogallo. In truth, that's probably the best choice right there. It's very rain-resistant, it's very large, and it tastes way better. It produces brebas, the figs don't ripen too late, and it's a very hardy tree. Really, it's a direct improvement to Longue d'Aout.

I'm flirting with the idea of doing this myself. Maybe I should just edit my Torbole listing and call it an improved Brown Turkey.

How to Find a Better Replacement for Any Fig


Whatever fig you're growing now, there's probably a variety that fills the same gaps and does it better.

Start with what your current fig does well, then look for a variety that does the same thing and also fills its gaps. My master variety table lets you compare breba, rain resistance, early ripening, size and flavor, and my Fig Variety Directory has a page for each variety.


Frequently Asked Questions


What is the worst fig variety?


For flavor, Iraqi is one of the worst I've grown, and it's in the Don't Recommend to Anyone tier on my Best Tasting list, along with Mega Celeste and Motoso Preto. Of the popular figs, I think Black Mission, English Brown Turkey (Olympian), California Brown Turkey and Columbaro Nero are the most overrated.

Is Brown Turkey a bad fig?


It's not a bad fig, but it's an inferior one. Both California and English Brown Turkey taste good when fully ripe in a dry climate. In humid climates, they often get bugs, spoil and mold before they get there. English Brown Turkey's brebas and cold hardiness are matched by better varieties, and California Brown Turkey is really a fig for commercial growers only.

What should I grow instead of Brown Turkey?


Instead of California Brown Turkey, I'd grow Torbole or Golden Rainbow. Instead of English Brown Turkey, I'd grow Green Michurinska, Vagabond, Moro de Caneva or Violette de Bordeaux.

What should I grow instead of Black Mission?


Pernette Noire and Sultane are my picks. Both improve on Black Mission, especially in rainy or humid climates.

Why does my fig tree's fruit taste bland?


Before you blame the variety, check two things. Some Common figs need pollination to develop their flavor, and dry soil can damage figs weeks before they ripen. If neither is the problem, the variety may just be average, and there's likely a better one that does the same job.

Grow a Better Fig


If you're growing one of these figs, that's not a bad thing. I'd rather you have a fig tree than no fig tree at all. But if it's not impressing you, first make sure it isn't a fig that needs pollination, and that it wasn't left dry. If it still disappoints, there's a better fig out there that does the same job, and a lot of them aren't hard to find. Life's too short to grow an average fig.



Don't forget to check out all of my fig trees for sale and the Fig Variety Directory to find more.
 
 
ross raddi_edited.jpg
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
I'm Ross, the "Fig Boss." I've been educating the world on the wonderful passion of growing fig trees for a decade. Apply my experiences to your own fig journey to grow the best tasting food possible.
POPULAR ARTICLES
  • Black YouTube Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Amazon
  • Gemini_Generated_Image_ksoquzksoquzksoq

TO GET OUR NEWSLETER AND NOTIFICATIONS FOR OUR BLOG

  • Black YouTube Icon
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • Amazon
  • Gemini_Generated_Image_ksoquzksoquzksoq

© 2019 by Ross Raddi. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page